← All Episodes

How Space Expansion Alters Light

By the Professor 42 min read 83 min listen

The Cosmic Canvas

This part will describe the observable universe and introduce the concept of what lies beyond it, using a play as a familiar reference.

The light is softening now, isn’t it? A slow wash of amber across the walls, and the edges of things beginning to blur. A stillness settles, not a silence exactly, but a quiet holding of breath. It’s a good time to consider the distances. To think about what lies beyond what we can easily see.

We carry the universe within us, of course. Not as a philosophical idea, but as a simple matter of composition. The calcium in your bones, forged in the heart of a dying star billions of years ago. The iron in your blood, scattered across the cosmos by supernovae. These elements, these building blocks of you, were once part of something unimaginably vast, something that continues to expand even as we speak. We are, in the most literal sense, stardust contemplating itself.

And that vastness, that expansion, has a limit. A boundary. A horizon. We call it the observable universe. It isn't a wall, not a physical edge you could fly toward and bump against. It's a sphere of space, centered on Earth, containing everything within reach of light that has had time to travel to us since the very beginning.

Imagine, for a moment, a single point of light, expanding outwards in all directions. That’s a crude analogy, of course, but it captures the essence of it. The universe isn’t expanding *into* anything, it’s simply that the space between things is growing. And because light has a finite speed – a little less than 300,000 kilometers per second – there’s a limit to how far we can see.

The radius of this sphere, the observable universe, is roughly 14.26 gigaparsecs. That’s a number that feels almost meaningless, doesn’t it? Gigaparsecs. It’s easier to think of it in light-years. About 46.5 billion light-years. Meaning that the light we see from the most distant objects has been travelling for 46.5 billion years to reach our eyes.

But here’s where it gets interesting, and where a little wonder begins to creep in. The universe is not just expanding, it’s expanding *faster* all the time. So, the distance to that horizon isn't fixed. It’s receding. Objects that are currently visible may, in the future, move beyond our ability to see them, carried away by the accelerating expansion. And objects that are currently beyond our horizon are moving away even faster.

Think of it like drawing a circle on a balloon as it’s being inflated. You’re the center of the circle, and everything within the circle is what you can see. But as the balloon inflates, the circle gets bigger, and the objects on the edge of the circle move further away from you, faster and faster. Eventually, they’ll be beyond your reach, lost in the expanding surface of the balloon.

It was Edwin Hubble, an American astronomer, who first demonstrated this expansion in 1929. He observed that galaxies are moving away from us at speeds proportional to their distance – the further away a galaxy is, the faster it’s receding. This relationship, now known as Hubble's law, is one of the cornerstones of modern cosmology. He didn’t discover the expansion itself, though; that honor belongs to Vesto Slipher, who meticulously measured the redshifts of distant galaxies, finding that the light from most of them was stretched, shifted towards the red end of the spectrum, an indication of movement away from us. Hubble simply quantified it, showed the direct relationship between distance and velocity.

But what lies beyond the observable universe? That’s a question that has captivated scientists and philosophers for centuries. The simplest answer is that it’s more universe. Perhaps infinite universe. Perhaps a universe with different laws of physics, different constants, different possibilities.

To understand this, it helps to think about the universe as a play. A vast, complex drama unfolding across space and time. We are sitting in the audience, watching a portion of the performance. We can see the actors on stage, hear their lines, witness their interactions. But we know, intuitively, that the stage doesn't end at the edge of our vision. There’s more to the theatre, more to the story, beyond what we can perceive. There are backstage areas, dressing rooms, perhaps even other stages, other plays unfolding simultaneously.

That’s the idea of the multiverse. A hypothetical set of all possible universes. Each universe a separate reality, with its own unique set of physical laws and constants. Some universes might be very similar to ours, with only slight variations. Others might be radically different, governed by laws we can’t even imagine.

The concept isn’t new. It has roots in ancient philosophy, in the idea of multiple worlds, of infinite possibilities. But it gained traction in modern physics with the development of quantum mechanics and the theory of cosmic inflation.

Cosmic inflation, a period of extremely rapid expansion in the very early universe, suggests that our observable universe is just a tiny bubble within a much larger, potentially infinite, multiverse. Think of it like boiling water. Bubbles form, expand, and eventually burst. Each bubble a separate universe, with its own unique properties.

And within this multiverse, the laws of physics might not be constant. They might vary from universe to universe, allowing for an infinite range of possibilities. Some universes might be hospitable to life, others might be completely barren. Some might have different dimensions, different forms of matter, different fundamental forces.

The idea is unsettling, isn’t it? To think that our universe, with all its complexity and beauty, might be just one of an infinite number of universes, a tiny speck in a vast, incomprehensible cosmos. But it’s also profoundly liberating. It suggests that the possibilities are endless, that anything is possible, somewhere in the multiverse.

Now, let’s return to the light. The light that reaches us from the most distant objects has been travelling for billions of years, stretched and distorted by the expansion of space. This light isn’t just a visual signal, it’s a snapshot of the early universe, a relic of a time when the cosmos was much hotter, denser, and more uniform. We call it the cosmic microwave background radiation, or CMB.

It’s a faint glow, almost uniform in all directions, but with tiny fluctuations, subtle variations in temperature. These fluctuations, discovered in 1965, are the seeds of all the structures we see today – galaxies, stars, planets, and ultimately, us. They represent the density variations in the early universe, the regions that were slightly more dense and eventually collapsed under gravity to form the structures we see around us.

The Planck spacecraft, operated by the European Space Agency from 2009 to 2013, mapped these fluctuations with unprecedented precision. It allowed scientists to study the early universe in incredible detail, to test cosmological theories about its composition and evolution. The data from Planck confirmed many of the predictions of the Big Bang theory, but also revealed some intriguing anomalies, some puzzles that remain unsolved.

The CMB is, in a sense, our ultimate horizon. It’s the furthest back in time we can see, the earliest snapshot of the universe. Beyond the CMB lies a realm we can’t directly observe, a realm shrouded in mystery. But we can still infer its properties, make educated guesses about what might lie beyond.

And it’s here that the idea of the cosmological horizon comes into play. This horizon divides space into those points reached by light traveling to an observer and those points too distant for light to have been observed. It’s a consequence of the expanding universe, of the finite speed of light.

The particle horizon, the boundary of the observable universe, is constantly receding. But there’s also an event horizon, which includes all possible future observations. Points outside the event horizon can never be observed, no matter how powerful our telescopes become.

These horizons are a reminder of our limitations, of the fact that we can only see a small portion of the universe. But they’re also a source of inspiration, a challenge to push the boundaries of our knowledge, to explore the mysteries that lie beyond.

The large-scale structure of the universe, the organization of matter at the largest scales, appears to follow a hierarchical model. Galaxies are grouped into clusters, clusters into superclusters, and superclusters into filaments, vast networks of galaxies stretching across billions of light-years. But beyond a certain scale – between 30 and 200 megaparsecs – there seems to be no continued structure. A phenomenon referred to as the “End of Greatness.” What lies beyond this end? Is it simply more of the same, a continuation of the hierarchical structure? Or is it something fundamentally different, a realm beyond our current understanding?

The expansion of the universe isn’t slowing down, as scientists once thought. It’s accelerating. And this acceleration is driven by a mysterious force called dark energy, which makes up about 68% of the universe’s total energy density. We don’t know what dark energy is, but it’s one of the biggest mysteries in modern cosmology. It could be a cosmological constant, an intrinsic property of space itself. Or it could be something more exotic, a new form of energy that we haven’t yet discovered.

The universe is a vast, complex, and mysterious place. We’ve made incredible progress in understanding its origins and evolution, but there’s still so much we don’t know. The observable universe is just a tiny portion of the cosmos, a small bubble within a potentially infinite multiverse. And beyond our horizon, beyond the CMB, beyond the End of Greatness, lie mysteries that await our discovery.

Perhaps, somewhere in that vastness, there are other universes, other realities, other possibilities. Perhaps there are other forms of life, other civilizations, other stories unfolding. We may never know. But the search for answers, the quest to understand our place in the cosmos, is a journey worth taking. And as we gaze out into the night sky, as we contemplate the distances, we can’t help but wonder what lies beyond the cosmic canvas, what secrets await us in the boundless night. The expansion continues, and the universe holds its breath, waiting to be revealed.

The Expansion of Space

This part will explain the mechanism of cosmic expansion and the role of dark energy in driving it.

The stillness deepens now, the light softening to a shade just beyond the reach of names. You are settled, I trust, into the quiet of it, the way a hand settles into a warm glove. We spoke last time of the universe as a sphere, a bubble of what we can see, and of the astonishing fact that its very fabric is stretching, carrying the galaxies outward like seeds scattered on an ever-expanding cloth. It is a strange thought, this expansion, and one that demands we reconsider what we mean by “space” itself. For it is not that the galaxies are *in* space, moving through it like ships on a sea. Rather, space itself is growing, and the galaxies are held within it, swept along with its relentless unfolding.

Imagine, if you will, a loaf of raisin bread rising in a warm kitchen. The dough is the universe, and the raisins are the galaxies. As the dough expands, each raisin moves farther away from every other raisin, not because it is traveling through the dough, but because the dough itself is growing. And if you were to stand on one raisin, you would observe all the others receding from you, the more distant ones moving away faster than the closer ones. This, in essence, is the expansion of the universe – a stretching of the very ground beneath our feet, a silent, inexorable growth that has been underway for nearly fourteen billion years.

This understanding did not arrive in a sudden flash of insight, but through the painstaking work of many hands, many eyes turned toward the faint glimmer of distant stars. In the 1920s, an American astronomer named Edwin Hubble, working at the Mount Wilson Observatory in California, began to meticulously measure the distances to these stars, and to the spiral nebulae that were then thought to be clouds within our own galaxy. Using a technique refined by Henrietta Swan Leavitt decades earlier – a relationship between the brightness of certain stars and the rhythm of their pulsations – Hubble was able to determine their true distances, a feat of immense precision that shattered our understanding of the cosmos. He found, to his astonishment, that these nebulae were not clouds within our galaxy at all, but entire galaxies, vast islands of stars lying far beyond the Milky Way.

But the true revelation came when he compared these distances to the velocities at which the galaxies were moving away from us. He discovered a remarkable correlation: the farther a galaxy was, the faster it was receding. This relationship, now known as Hubble’s law, was a profound confirmation of the idea that the universe is expanding. It wasn't merely that galaxies were moving, but that they were being carried apart by the very structure of space itself.

Yet Hubble's law only described *that* the universe expands; it did not explain *why*. The question of what force was driving this expansion remained one of the most profound mysteries in cosmology. For decades, scientists assumed that gravity – the force that holds us to the Earth, that governs the motion of the planets, that shapes the very structure of stars – must be slowing down the expansion, gradually bringing everything back together. After all, gravity is an attractive force, and it seemed intuitive that it would eventually overcome the initial impetus of the expansion.

This assumption was rooted in the prevailing understanding of the universe as a static, unchanging entity. Albert Einstein, in his theory of general relativity, had initially proposed a cosmological constant – a sort of anti-gravity force – to counteract the pull of gravity and keep the universe from collapsing. But when Hubble’s observations revealed the expansion, Einstein famously called this the “biggest blunder of my life,” abandoning the constant as unnecessary. It seemed far more logical that the expansion was simply a remnant of the initial Big Bang, a slowing-down process that would eventually come to a halt.

But the universe, as it often does, had other plans. In the late 1990s, two independent teams of astronomers, studying distant supernovae – exploding stars – made a startling discovery. These supernovae, used as standard candles to measure cosmic distances, were fainter than expected, indicating that they were farther away than they should have been if the expansion was slowing down. In fact, the observations suggested that the expansion of the universe was not slowing down at all, but accelerating.

This discovery was revolutionary, and it pointed to the existence of a mysterious force, a sort of anti-gravity, that was driving the accelerating expansion. This force, dubbed “dark energy,” remains one of the greatest puzzles in modern cosmology. It makes up approximately 68% of the total energy density of the universe, yet its nature is almost entirely unknown. We know *that* it exists, because we can observe its effects on the expansion of the universe, but we have little understanding of *what* it is.

Imagine a vast, dark ocean, and you are a small boat adrift on its surface. You can feel the currents pushing you along, but you cannot see the source of those currents, cannot understand the forces that are shaping your journey. Dark energy is like those unseen currents, a pervasive force that is shaping the fate of the universe, yet remains hidden from our direct observation.

The leading theory suggests that dark energy is a property of space itself, an inherent energy density that remains constant as the universe expands. This is, in effect, a revival of Einstein’s cosmological constant, though with a crucial difference: rather than being a fixed value, it is a dynamic quantity that drives the accelerating expansion. As the universe expands, more space is created, and with it, more dark energy, fueling the accelerating expansion in a runaway effect.

But even this explanation leaves many questions unanswered. Why is the energy density of dark energy so small? Why is it so uniform throughout the universe? And what will happen in the distant future as the expansion continues to accelerate? These are questions that cosmologists are grappling with today, pushing the boundaries of our understanding of the cosmos.

To understand this accelerating expansion, we must delve deeper into the fabric of space itself, to consider the very nature of the vacuum, the seemingly empty void that permeates the universe. Quantum mechanics, the theory that governs the behavior of matter at the atomic and subatomic level, suggests that even empty space is not truly empty, but is filled with fleeting, virtual particles that constantly pop into and out of existence. These particles, though short-lived, possess energy, and this energy could contribute to the dark energy density of the universe.

However, calculations based on quantum mechanics predict a far greater energy density than what is actually observed, a discrepancy known as the cosmological constant problem. This is one of the most significant unsolved problems in physics, and it suggests that our understanding of the vacuum is fundamentally incomplete.

The search for dark energy is a quest to understand the very nature of reality, to unravel the mysteries of space, time, and the universe itself. It is a journey that will require new theoretical insights, new observational techniques, and perhaps, a radical rethinking of our fundamental assumptions about the cosmos.

Consider, for a moment, the implications of this accelerating expansion. As the universe continues to grow, the galaxies will move farther and farther apart, eventually receding beyond our observable horizon. The light from these distant galaxies will become increasingly redshifted, stretched to longer and longer wavelengths, eventually fading into invisibility. In the distant future, billions of years from now, our descendants will be able to see only the galaxies within our local group, a small island of stars surrounded by an ever-darkening void.

The universe, in effect, will become increasingly isolated, a lonely expanse of space populated by a dwindling number of galaxies. The cosmic microwave background, the faint afterglow of the Big Bang, will continue to cool and fade, eventually becoming undetectable. The universe will become increasingly empty, increasingly dark, increasingly silent.

This is, of course, a distant future, one that lies far beyond the scope of human comprehension. But it is a future that is dictated by the relentless expansion of space, driven by the mysterious force of dark energy. And as we continue to unravel the secrets of dark energy, we will gain a deeper understanding of the fate of the universe, and our place within it. The expansion, you see, isn’t simply a phenomenon happening ‘out there’—it is woven into the very structure of existence, a fundamental property of the cosmos that shapes our past, our present, and our future, and it is a property that continues to reveal itself, slowly, patiently, with each new observation and each new theoretical insight. The universe is not merely expanding *in* space, it is expanding *with* space, and that subtle distinction holds the key to understanding the boundless night that lies before us.

The Edge of Knowledge

This part will explore the limits of our understanding of the universe and the challenges in studying what lies beyond the observable universe.

The light has softened further now, hasn’t it? The edges of things seem to blur a little more each moment, as if the room itself is yielding, expanding gently into the stillness. It’s a curious sensation, this feeling of boundaries dissolving, and perhaps a fitting one for what we were discussing last time – the universe unfolding, stretching outward, carrying galaxies with it like dust motes in an infinite current. We spoke of a loaf of bread, of raisins receding from one another, a simple image to hold the vastness of Hubble’s discovery. But simplicity, as often happens, is a doorway, not a destination. It’s enough to begin there, to feel the pull of that expansion, but it doesn't tell the whole story, and it doesn’t speak to the limits of what we can truly know.

Because what lies beyond what we can see, beyond the furthest reach of light, is not simply *more* universe, more galaxies, more of the same. It is, instead, a region governed by rules subtly, fundamentally different from those we experience here, in the familiar neighbourhood of our own galaxy. It’s a place where the very act of observation becomes a paradox, where the definitions of distance and time begin to fray at the edges, and where the neat, tidy explanations we build so carefully start to unravel.

Consider for a moment the light itself, the messenger that brings us these distant glimpses of creation. It travels, of course, at a finite speed—a speed that, while immense, is nonetheless limited. This means that when we look at a galaxy, say, ten billion light-years away, we are not seeing it as it is *now*, but as it was ten billion years ago. The light we detect has been journeying for ten billion years to reach us, carrying an image of a past long gone. And the further we look, the further back in time we see.

This brings us to a boundary, a sphere around us called the particle horizon. Imagine standing on the shore of an ocean, watching waves roll in. You can see a certain distance out, limited by the curvature of the Earth and the clarity of the air. Beyond that horizon, the ocean continues, of course, but you cannot *see* it. The particle horizon is similar, but instead of waves, it’s light, and instead of the Earth’s curvature, it’s the finite age and expansion rate of the universe. Everything within that horizon is, in principle, observable, because light from those objects has had enough time to reach us. Everything beyond it remains hidden, shrouded in a darkness that is not simply a lack of light, but a limit imposed by the very nature of spacetime.

And that horizon isn’t fixed. As time passes, light from more distant objects *will* eventually reach us, expanding the observable universe. But the expansion itself is accelerating, driven by this mysterious dark energy we touched on before. This acceleration has a curious effect: the further an object is from us, the faster it recedes, and the faster its light is stretched, diluted, and ultimately lost to us. There’s a point, a cosmic distance, beyond which the expansion is so rapid that light emitted from objects beyond that point will *never* reach us, no matter how long we wait.

This boundary, the ultimate limit of what we can observe, is called the event horizon. It's a more fundamental limit than the particle horizon, because it’s not simply a matter of waiting for light to arrive. It's a consequence of the very fabric of spacetime, of the accelerating expansion pushing everything away from us faster than light can travel. It’s a boundary that is receding faster than light, so it’s not a horizon we can ever hope to cross, not even in principle.

The implications of this are profound. It means that there is a vast, unknowable universe beyond our reach, a region that will forever remain hidden from our observations. It’s a humbling thought, isn’t it? To realize that our entire understanding of the cosmos, our maps of galaxies and nebulae, our theories of the Big Bang, are all limited to a tiny, finite bubble within an infinite expanse.

But the story doesn’t end there. The very attempt to understand these limits reveals something deeper about the nature of reality. To define a horizon is to define a boundary, and to define a boundary is to acknowledge something *outside* that boundary. The event horizon isn't just a place we can't see; it’s a consequence of the geometry of spacetime, of the way space and time are intertwined. And that geometry is governed by the laws of physics, laws that we believe, at least in principle, are universal.

This is where things get truly strange. The universe we observe is remarkably uniform, on the largest scales. Galaxies are distributed in a web-like structure, with vast voids separating dense clusters, but if you smooth out those irregularities, the universe appears, on average, to be the same in every direction. This uniformity is a puzzle, because the early universe was not uniform. In the moments after the Big Bang, there were tiny fluctuations in density, quantum ripples that eventually grew into the galaxies and structures we see today. But how did these tiny fluctuations spread across the entire universe, smoothing out the irregularities and creating the homogeneity we observe?

The answer, according to the prevailing theory, lies in a period of incredibly rapid expansion called inflation. In the very first fraction of a second after the Big Bang, the universe underwent an exponential burst of growth, expanding faster than the speed of light. This inflation stretched out any initial irregularities, smoothing out the universe and creating the uniformity we observe today.

But inflation itself is a mystery. We don’t know what caused it, or why it stopped. And it raises a troubling question: if inflation happened, it must have happened everywhere, creating not just one universe, but an infinite number of them, each with slightly different properties. This leads to the concept of the multiverse, a hypothetical set of parallel universes, each a bubble of spacetime with its own laws of physics, its own constants, its own history.

The idea is unsettling, isn't it? To imagine our universe as just one tiny bubble in an infinite ocean of other universes, each potentially vastly different from our own. It challenges our fundamental notion of reality, of what it means to exist. And it raises the question of whether these other universes are even knowable, whether we can ever hope to understand the true nature of the multiverse.

The Planck spacecraft, launched by the European Space Agency in 2009, was designed to probe the cosmic microwave background radiation, the faint afterglow of the Big Bang. It mapped the tiny temperature fluctuations in this radiation with unprecedented precision, providing a snapshot of the early universe. And what it found was…intriguing. The fluctuations were remarkably consistent with the predictions of inflation, but they also revealed some anomalies, some unexpected patterns that don’t quite fit the standard model.

These anomalies could be due to a number of factors, perhaps systematic errors in the data, or perhaps they are a sign of something truly new, something beyond our current understanding. Some physicists have suggested that they could be evidence of collisions with other universes, ripples in spacetime caused by the interaction of our bubble with another.

But even if we could confirm the existence of these anomalies, it wouldn’t necessarily tell us much about the other universes. We would only be seeing the faint imprint of their existence, a shadow of their reality. The true nature of the multiverse, if it exists, may forever remain beyond our grasp.

Consider the work of Alexander Friedmann, a Russian physicist who, in the 1920s, developed the equations that describe an expanding universe. He showed that Einstein’s original static model of the universe was unstable, that it would inevitably either expand or contract. His work was initially dismissed by Einstein, who was reluctant to accept the idea of an evolving universe. It wasn’t until Edwin Hubble’s observations confirmed the expansion that Friedmann’s work was recognized as a groundbreaking achievement.

Friedmann’s equations are elegant and powerful, but they also have limitations. They assume that the universe is homogeneous and isotropic, that it looks the same in every direction and from every location. But we know that the universe is not perfectly homogeneous. There are galaxies, clusters, voids, and large-scale structures that break this symmetry. And as we probe deeper into the universe, we may find that these inhomogeneities become more significant, challenging the validity of Friedmann’s equations.

And what about the very laws of physics themselves? Are they the same everywhere, in every universe? Or could they vary, changing with time and location? The multiverse suggests that they could, that each universe could have its own set of laws, its own constants, its own fundamental principles.

This leads us to a profound question: what defines reality? Is it the laws of physics, the constants, the equations that govern the behavior of matter and energy? Or is it something more, something beyond our comprehension?

The edge of knowledge is not a fixed boundary, but a shifting horizon, constantly receding as we push the limits of our understanding. It’s a place of uncertainty, of mystery, of unanswered questions. But it’s also a place of wonder, of possibility, of endless exploration. And it's a place where the very act of seeking knowledge becomes a journey into the unknown, a testament to the enduring power of the human spirit. The universe, in its vastness and complexity, may forever remain beyond our complete grasp, but the pursuit of understanding is a reward in itself, a journey that expands our minds and deepens our appreciation for the beauty and mystery of existence.

And as we continue to explore, as we build more powerful telescopes, as we develop more sophisticated theories, we may find that the limits of our knowledge are not a barrier, but an invitation, a challenge to push further, to delve deeper, to unravel the secrets of the cosmos and our place within it. The faint glow of the cosmic microwave background, the receding horizon of the event horizon, the tantalizing possibility of the multiverse—these are not endpoints, but doorways, beckoning us onward into the boundless night.

Probing the Cosmos with WMAP and Planck

This part will discuss the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe and the Planck satellite, the tools used to map the cosmic microwave background radiation and study the large-scale structure of the universe.

The light has settled now, hasn’t it? A stillness deepens, not the absence of things but a softening around their edges, a quiet acceptance of distance. It is a fitting state, perhaps, to consider the furthest reaches of what we can know, because knowing itself is a process of reaching, of stretching toward a boundary that always recedes. We spoke last of that boundary, the particle horizon, and the even more distant event horizon beyond it—limits not of space itself, but of the time light has had to travel to us. And within that vastness, within the sphere of the observable universe, lies a faint echo, a whisper of the very early cosmos: the cosmic microwave background.

It is a strange thing to consider, that almost every direction you look, if you had an instrument sensitive enough, you would detect this uniform glow, a residue of heat from a time when the universe was young and dense, a mere 380,000 years after its beginning. Imagine that beginning, not as an explosion into emptiness, but as a transition from a state we can scarcely comprehend—opaque, superheated, a plasma of particles constantly interacting—to one where photons could finally travel freely. Before that moment, light was trapped, bouncing from particle to particle, unable to escape. Then, as the universe expanded and cooled, electrons combined with protons to form neutral hydrogen, and suddenly, the universe became transparent. This is the moment the cosmic microwave background was released, a flash of light that has been stretched and cooled by the expansion of space ever since, arriving now as microwave radiation.

But it isn’t perfectly uniform, is it? That faint glow isn’t quite the same in every direction. There are tiny fluctuations, variations in temperature on the order of a few parts per million—anomalies, the scientists call them—and it is within these anomalies that the story of the universe truly begins to unfold. These minuscule differences in temperature represent the seeds of all the structure we see today: the galaxies, the clusters of galaxies, the vast filaments and voids that make up the cosmic web. To map these fluctuations, to understand their origin and evolution, required instruments of extraordinary sensitivity, built not on Earth, but in the cold, clear vacuum of space.

The first detailed map of the cosmic microwave background came from the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe, or WMAP, launched in 2001. Think of the instrument itself, not as a single lens or mirror, but as a series of increasingly shielded rooms, each designed to isolate the faintest possible signal from the noise of the universe. The satellite was positioned far from Earth, at what’s called the Sun-Earth L2 Lagrange point—a gravitationally stable location where it could maintain a constant view of the sky, shielded from the heat and interference of our planet. Inside, layers of baffles absorbed stray light and radio waves, cooling the detectors to a mere 90 Kelvin—that is, 90 degrees above absolute zero, colder than the surface of Pluto. And even then, the signal was so faint, so subtle, that it was necessary to scan the entire sky multiple times, carefully subtracting out any remaining noise and interference.

Imagine standing at the control console, watching the data stream in, slowly building a picture of the early universe. The detectors weren’t measuring color, of course—the wavelengths of the cosmic microwave background are far beyond the visible spectrum—but they were measuring intensity, the strength of the microwave signal at each point in the sky. As the satellite scanned, this intensity was translated into a color map, with warmer regions appearing as red and cooler regions as blue. The resulting image, when it was finally released, was breathtaking. It showed a universe filled with tiny, swirling patterns, like eddies in a vast cosmic ocean. It wasn’t a smooth, uniform glow, but a complex tapestry of hot and cold spots, each representing a slight density fluctuation in the early universe.

The process of building that map, though, was far from simple. Each detector was essentially a sensitive thermometer, measuring the energy of the incoming photons. But photons aren’t all the same energy, and the instrument needed to be calibrated to account for the varying wavelengths. This involved carefully observing known sources of microwave radiation, like the cosmic microwave background itself, and comparing the measured signal to the expected value. It was a painstaking process, requiring years of careful analysis and refinement. And even then, there was always the possibility of systematic errors, subtle biases in the data that could lead to false conclusions.

Then, in 2013, came Planck, a successor to WMAP, with even greater sensitivity and resolution. Built by the European Space Agency, Planck carried not one, but three instruments, each designed to observe the cosmic microwave background at different wavelengths. The Low Frequency Instrument, or LFI, measured the signal at longer wavelengths, while the High Frequency Instrument, or HFI, measured it at shorter wavelengths. Together, these instruments provided a more complete picture of the cosmic microwave background than ever before.

Consider the HFI, for example. It used detectors called bolometers, which are essentially tiny, superconducting thermometers. These bolometers were cooled to an astonishing 0.1 Kelvin—that is, just one-tenth of a degree above absolute zero, the coldest temperature ever achieved in space. To achieve this level of cooling, the instrument used a series of cryocoolers, complex machines that removed heat from the detectors using a process called adiabatic demagnetization. Imagine the detectors themselves, suspended in a vacuum, shielded from all sources of light and heat, cooled to a temperature colder than interstellar space.

The photons from the cosmic microwave background, when they finally reached the bolometers, would cause a tiny increase in temperature. This temperature change was then measured with incredible precision, allowing scientists to determine the intensity of the microwave signal at each point in the sky. But even then, the signal was so faint that it was necessary to scan the entire sky multiple times, carefully averaging the data to reduce the noise. And even then, there was always the possibility of systematic errors, subtle biases in the data that could lead to false conclusions.

The Planck mission, over its four years of operation, scanned the entire sky six times, building a map of the cosmic microwave background with unprecedented detail. The resulting image revealed a universe even more complex than WMAP had shown. It confirmed many of the predictions of the standard cosmological model, the Lambda-CDM model, which posits that the universe is composed of dark energy, dark matter, and ordinary matter. But it also revealed some surprising anomalies, unexpected patterns in the data that couldn’t be explained by the standard model.

One of the most intriguing anomalies was a large, cold spot in the sky, a region with a lower temperature than expected. This cold spot, which is located in the constellation Eridanus, is far larger than it should be, according to the standard model. Some scientists have suggested that it could be a statistical fluke, a random fluctuation in the data. But others have proposed more exotic explanations, such as the existence of a parallel universe, or a collision with another bubble universe.

Another anomaly was a slight alignment of the largest structures in the universe, a tendency for galaxies to be oriented in the same direction. This alignment is unexpected, according to the standard model, which predicts that the distribution of galaxies should be random. Some scientists have suggested that it could be a sign of new physics, a fundamental flaw in our understanding of the universe.

These anomalies, while intriguing, are still not fully understood. They could be the result of systematic errors, subtle biases in the data that haven’t yet been identified. Or they could be the first signs of new physics, a fundamental flaw in our understanding of the universe. Whatever the explanation, they remind us that our knowledge of the cosmos is still incomplete, that there are still mysteries to be solved.

And it is in this process of seeking, of questioning, of refining our understanding, that the true beauty of science lies. The instruments—WMAP and Planck—are not merely tools for measuring the universe, but extensions of our own senses, allowing us to see further, to hear fainter whispers, to probe deeper into the mysteries of existence. The data they provide is not simply a collection of numbers, but a window into the early universe, a glimpse of a time when the cosmos was young and dense, a time when the seeds of all structure were sown. The anomalies, the unexpected patterns, are not simply errors to be corrected, but clues to be deciphered, hints of a deeper reality that lies beyond our current understanding.

What this means is that the universe, as we observe it, is not a simple, uniform entity, but a complex, dynamic system, filled with subtle variations and unexpected patterns. And it is within these variations and patterns that the story of the universe truly unfolds, a story that we are only beginning to understand. The maps produced by WMAP and Planck have revealed the skeleton of the cosmos, the underlying structure that governs the distribution of galaxies and the evolution of the universe. But they have also revealed a universe that is more complex and mysterious than we ever imagined, a universe that continues to challenge our assumptions and push the boundaries of our knowledge. The faint glow of the cosmic microwave background, a relic of the early universe, continues to whisper its secrets, inviting us to explore further, to question deeper, to reach for the furthest horizons of what we can know.

The Boundless Night

This part will reflect on the vastness of the universe and the mysteries that lie beyond our current reach.

The light has softened further, hasn’t it? A quietening, not just in the room, but in the very thought of distance. We spoke last time of reaching, of instruments straining toward the faintest echoes of the early universe, of mapping the subtle temperature differences in the cosmic microwave background – those almost imperceptible fluctuations that seeded the structures we see today. And it’s worth lingering there, on the edge of what we can know, because that edge isn’t a fixed point. It recedes. It always recedes, pulled backward by the very expansion it reveals.

The maps produced by the Planck satellite, and before it by WMAP, are, in a way, portraits of a past so distant it’s almost ungraspable. Imagine, if you will, not just looking back in time – which we do, of course, every time we observe distant objects, because light takes time to travel – but looking back at a time when the universe was so young it was almost entirely uniform. A hot, dense plasma, opaque and featureless, expanding rapidly, cooling as it grew. And then, roughly 380,000 years after the beginning, a moment of transparency. Electrons and protons combined, forming neutral hydrogen, and suddenly, light could travel freely. That light, stretched and cooled by the expansion of space itself, is what we detect today as the cosmic microwave background. It’s a photograph of the universe at infancy, a snapshot of a moment when it was barely recognizable as the cosmos we inhabit.

But that photograph isn't perfectly clear. There are fluctuations, tiny variations in temperature – on the order of a few microkelvins out of an average temperature of 2.7 kelvins – and those fluctuations are everything. They represent the seeds of all the galaxies, stars, planets, and ultimately, ourselves. These weren’t random, of course. They were, as far as we can tell, quantum fluctuations amplified by the rapid expansion of the early universe. A process that began in a state of almost perfect homogeneity, and then, through the relentless pull of gravity, began to coalesce into structure.

The way Planck mapped these fluctuations is a story in itself. The satellite wasn’t looking for visible light, or even infrared. It was detecting microwaves, specifically the faint radiation emitted by the CMB. And to detect such a faint signal, it had to be incredibly cold, shielded from any interference from Earth, the sun, even the satellite itself. It was placed in a stable orbit at the Sun-Earth L2 Lagrange point, a gravitational sweet spot about 1.5 million kilometers away from Earth, where the gravitational forces of the sun and Earth balance each other out. There, shielded from our planet's warmth, it could scan the sky, slowly building up a map of the CMB with unprecedented precision.

The instruments themselves were marvels of engineering. Two main instruments, the Low Frequency Instrument, or LFI, and the High Frequency Instrument, or HFI. Both relied on incredibly sensitive detectors called bolometers. These aren't like the CCDs in a digital camera, which convert light into electrical signals. Bolometers measure the energy of incoming radiation by detecting the tiny temperature increase it causes in a superconducting material. They need to be cooled to fractions of a degree above absolute zero – colder than the vacuum of space itself – to minimize any noise. And they scan the sky not by pointing and shooting, but by slowly rotating the satellite, allowing the detectors to sweep across the CMB.

George Smoot, who shared the 2006 Nobel Prize for his work on the Cosmic Background Explorer, or COBE, a precursor to WMAP and Planck, described the early data as a whisper of the early cosmos. It took years of painstaking analysis to remove the noise and reveal the underlying pattern. And when they finally did, it was a revelation. The fluctuations weren’t random; they followed a statistical distribution predicted by the theory of inflation – the idea that the universe underwent a period of incredibly rapid expansion in its earliest moments.

But the story doesn't end there. The maps produced by Planck aren't perfect. There are anomalies, features that don't quite fit the standard cosmological model. The largest of these is the “cold spot,” a region in the constellation Eridanus that is significantly colder than the surrounding areas. Its existence is difficult to explain within the standard model, and it has led to speculation about exotic possibilities, like the existence of other universes bumping into our own. There's also the alignment of galaxy orientations, which seems to be correlated with the CMB fluctuations in a way that shouldn't be possible if the universe is truly isotropic – the same in all directions.

These anomalies are not necessarily evidence of flaws in the cosmological model. They could simply be statistical flukes, rare events that happen by chance. But they are reminders that our understanding of the universe is incomplete, that there are still mysteries to be solved. And they point to the limits of our knowledge, to the vastness of the unknown that lies beyond the observable universe.

Consider this: the observable universe – everything we can see – is a sphere with a radius of about 46.5 billion light-years. That’s a staggering distance, almost incomprehensible. But it’s just a tiny fraction of the entire universe, which may be infinite in size. And the universe is expanding, accelerating in its expansion, driven by a mysterious force we call dark energy. This dark energy makes up about 68% of the universe's total energy density, and we have no idea what it is. It’s a placeholder for something we don’t understand, a name for the force that is pushing the universe apart.

The expansion of the universe also means that there’s a cosmological horizon, a boundary beyond which we can never see. This horizon isn’t a physical barrier, like the edge of a cliff. It’s a consequence of the finite speed of light and the expansion of space. Light from objects beyond the cosmological horizon hasn’t had time to reach us yet, and it will never reach us, because the universe is expanding faster than the speed of light.

Alexander Friedmann, a Russian physicist who first proposed the idea of an expanding universe in the 1920s, understood this implicitly. He developed a set of equations – the Friedmann equations – that describe the evolution of the universe, showing that it could be expanding or contracting, depending on its density. His work was largely ignored at the time, because it contradicted the prevailing view of a static, eternal universe. It was Edwin Hubble, who confirmed the expansion of the universe through his observations of receding galaxies, that finally validated Friedmann’s theory. Vesto Slipher’s earlier measurements of redshift in those galaxies provided the crucial data Hubble built upon.

And this is where the truly unsettling part begins. If the universe is expanding, and there’s a cosmological horizon, then there must be regions of space that are beyond our reach, forever disconnected from us. These regions may have different physical laws, different constants of nature, even different dimensions. They may be completely unlike anything we can imagine. The idea of a multiverse – a hypothetical set of all possible universes – arises from this possibility.

The multiverse isn’t a single theory, but a collection of ideas. Some versions propose that our universe is just one bubble in a vast foam of universes, constantly forming and popping into existence. Others suggest that every quantum measurement creates a new universe, branching off from our own. The multiverse is a radical idea, and it’s difficult to test empirically. But it’s a logical consequence of our current understanding of physics, a natural extension of the cosmological model.

The large-scale structure of the universe – the distribution of galaxies, stars, and voids – also provides clues about the early universe. Sky surveys have revealed a complex network of filaments and clusters, a cosmic web that spans billions of light-years. This web is thought to have formed from the tiny fluctuations in the CMB, amplified by gravity over billions of years. But beyond a certain scale – about 200 megaparsecs – the structure seems to disappear, reaching what’s been called the “End of Greatness.” This suggests that there’s a limit to the size of the structures that can form in the universe, a boundary beyond which the universe becomes homogeneous again.

And then there’s the cosmological constant, Albert Einstein’s greatest blunder, as he called it. He introduced it into his equations of general relativity to create a static universe, but later removed it when he learned that the universe was expanding. But the discovery of dark energy has revived the cosmological constant, suggesting that it’s a real physical phenomenon, a property of space itself.

The more we learn about the universe, the more we realize how little we know. We’ve mapped the cosmic microwave background with incredible precision, but there are still anomalies that we can’t explain. We’ve discovered dark energy, but we don’t know what it is. We’ve proposed the multiverse, but we can’t prove it exists. The universe is vast, complex, and mysterious, and it’s likely that we’ll never fully understand it.

But that’s not a cause for despair. It’s a cause for wonder. The fact that there are still mysteries to be solved, that there’s still so much to learn, is what makes science so exciting. And the tools we’ve developed to explore the universe – the telescopes, satellites, and detectors – are marvels of human ingenuity. They are a testament to our curiosity, our desire to understand the world around us.

And as we look out into the boundless night, at the faint glow of the cosmic microwave background, we’re not just looking at the past. We’re looking at the potential for the future. We’re looking at the possibility of discovering new laws of physics, new universes, new realities. The universe is open to us, waiting to be explored.

The patterns we’ve mapped, the fluctuations we’ve detected, they are not simply data points on a graph. They are echoes of the beginning, whispers of a time when the universe was born. And they are, in a very real sense, a part of us. We are made of stardust, after all, forged in the hearts of dying stars. And we are connected to the universe in a fundamental way, bound together by gravity, energy, and the relentless march of time.

The light continues to fade, and with it, the sharp edges of thought soften. The universe, in its vastness, holds its secrets close, and there is a quiet comfort in knowing that some mysteries may remain forever beyond our grasp. The patterns we see in the CMB, the delicate fluctuations that seeded the cosmos, they are a part of you now, a quiet resonance within. And as you settle, as the boundaries between thought and dream begin to blur, remember that even in the face of the infinite, there is a profound beauty in the questions themselves, a gentle hum of wonder that echoes through the darkness. The universe expands, and within that expansion, there is space for everything, for every possibility, for every dream.

Browse All Episodes